By Ezio Di Nucci

Ethics with out goal tackles the questions raised through tough ethical dilemmas through supplying a severe research of double impact and its most typical moral and political functions. The ebook discusses the philosophical contrast among meant damage and foreseen yet accidental damage. This contrast, which, based on the doctrine of double impact, makes a distinction to the ethical justification of activities, is broadly utilized to a couple of the main debatable moral and political questions of our time: collateral damages in wars and acts of terrorism; palliative care, euthanasia, abortion, and embryo examine; self-defence, suicide, and self-sacrifice. it's also the most important to the now infamous theoretical circumstances of the trolley challenge and the knobe influence. Di Nucci methods the doctrine of double influence from 4 key instructions: its ancient origins, which might be traced extra again than the vintage attribution to Aquinas; its theoretical coherence, that is the topic of a full of life modern debate in philosophy; its ethical intuitiveness, which has constantly been taken without any consideration yet has lately started to be puzzled; and eventually its relevance to the tricky ethical and political judgements of our time. an attractive and finished advent to the doctrine of double influence.

Show description

Read Online or Download Ethics Without Intention PDF

Best ethics books

Francis Bacon's "Inquiry Touching Human Nature": Virtue, Philosophy, and the Relief of Man's Estate

Francis Bacon's "Inquiry Touching Human Nature" is a learn of Francis Bacon's ethical philosophy in its relation to the enlightenment venture he helped release. in view that Bacon is among the founders of technological modernity, the publication offers a meditation at the presuppositions and personality of recent existence.

Confronting Managerialism: How the Business Elite and Their Schools Threw Our Lives Out of Balance

Confronting Managerialism bargains a scathing critique of the crippling impact of neoclassical economics and sleek finance on company tuition educating and administration perform. It exhibits how enterprise managers, as soon as good considered as custodians of the industrial engine riding progress and social development, now look extra just like the rapacious "robber barons" of the Eighteen Eighties.

Corporate Social Responsibility in India: Cases and Developments After the Legal Mandate

This ebook presents a accomplished review of company Social accountability (CSR) in Indian businesses following the 2013 felony mandate on company spending of gains for CSR. Bringing jointly authors hailing from different walks of lifestyles, the publication pursues a 'hands-on' process, with real-world case experiences and examples that support the reader believe the dynamic pulse of India instantly after the ratification of the CSR mandate within the businesses Act, 2013.

Additional info for Ethics Without Intention

Sample text

Let me clarify that the point of this section is only to show that the counterfactual test alone will not distinguish between intended means and merely foreseen side effects; it is neither to claim that we cannot distinguish between intended means and side effects (otherwise, the book would be already over with this section), nor is it to claim that the counterfactual test is in itself useless. Indeed, at least the latter point is probably false: compare Terror Bomber with Sadistic Bomber. The former is someone who intends to kill school children in order to demoralize the enemy; given that the involvement of school children in her plan only serves the purpose of demoralizing the enemy, Terror Bomber would not intend to kill the school children in a counterfactual scenario where she does not have the end of demoralizing the enemy nor would she intend to kill the children in a counterfactual scenario where she can demoralize the enemy without killing the children – whatever you make of these counterfactuals, they can certainly be stipulated.

I have been comparing the case in which the agent saves his family with cases of double effect, while Pakaluk compares the case in which the agent does not save his family with cases of double effect. Here then the bad effect is the death of the family while the good effect is that the agent does an honourable thing in refusing to do something base, supposedly. There are two things to note about Pakaluk’s alternative reading: first, notice that here the proposed application of the Doctrine of Double Effect is for an intentional omission rather than for an action: the agent refuses or omits to do the base thing; none of the standard scenarios in the debate on double effect are such that the Doctrine is used to justify an omission; the Doctrine is rather normally used to justify an intervention: think, for example, of the bystander who may omit to divert the trolley from the five to the one but who, according to the Doctrine, may justifiably divert the trolley from the five to the one.

ARISTOTLE, AQUINAS AND THE ORIGINS OF DOUBLE EFFECT 43 3 Double effect Aristotle’s two cases are strikingly similar to the classic examples in the Double Effect debate. I will mention here five kinds of examples which I take to be the most common ones8 – the details of the cases have already been introduced in Chapter 1: 1 Terror Bombing. A good illustration of this case is 2 3 4 5 provided by Bratman (1987: 139–40, already illustrated in Chapter 1); Trolley Problem. The Trolley Problem was first introduced by Foot (19679) even though its most influential formulation is Thomson’s (1976 and 1985) variation on Foot’s original case – the next chapter will deal with the trolley problem in more detail; Craniotomy, which goes back to Foot’s influential discussion (1967); Death-inducing pain alleviation.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.94 of 5 – based on 14 votes